In this preview of Billy Eichner’s Carpool Karaoke episode with Metallica, Eichner try to make James, Lars, Kirk and Robert crack a smile while playing a hard-rocking version of “Never Have I Ever” re-named “Metal Have I Ever.”
In this game, instead of holding up five fingers, the fellas have to hold up metal fingers. “Metal have I ever listened to Paula Cole to unwind,” Eichner asks to a car full of blank stares. “Who’s Paula Cole?” asks a confused Lars Ulrich as it dawns on Eichner that his carpoolers have never seen Dawson’s Creek. More hilarity ensues as Eichner asks the band about yogurt, if they’ve ever sent a d*** pic, and then forces them to sing a Disney song.
Check out the entire video at applemusic.com/carpoolkaraoke.